"Weigh too Much" is the fourth challenge in the second episode of Season One, "Butterfly Crime Scene". The guys have to stack frozen yogurt toppings and make huge yogurts, then find a way to pay as little as possible. Originally, the loser of this challenge is the person who pays the most, but since Joe got kicked out of the shop without his yogurt, he was the one with the loss. Murr paid $2, Sal paid 14¢, and Q paid nothing.