Penny for your Thoughts is a challenge in the episodes Elephant in the Room and Fe-Mail. The jokers had to tell a stranger their "thoughts", which were made up by the other guys. Not saying the thought that they were given would make them lose.
Elephant in the Room (Joker vs. Joker)
This was a Joker vs. Joker Challenge between Sal and Q and was the fourth and final challenge in the episode. Sal lost this challenge because he has a laughing fit. He was laughing too hard from hearing that "Fluoride in the water is giving my son bitch tittays." He gave up after too many tries from laughing over it.
This time around, all four jokers got to compete and this was the second challenge of the episode. Nobody lost.