The guys act not so silent at a library, and hunt for their imaginary wives again at the mall.
- Goal: Don't get shushed
- Loser: Q and Sal lost but neither of them were directly shushed. Q lost because someone took his air horn prop, Sal lost because he left the room in embarrassment after using his cymbals prop.
The guys are in a library doing loud noises to the other people inside. They have to pull a loud prop out of their bag and use it. The challenge goes with two jokers against each other, then the other two jokers against each other. Joe and Q went against each other first, then Sal and Murr. The goal is not to get "shushed." The joker on each side who goes the longest without a shush wins.
- Goal: Get someone to say they've seen your wife.
- Loser: Sal, Q, and Joe
The guys are in a mall and have to ask strangers if they have seen the joker's wife using embarrassing clues given by the other guys. The clues are embarrassing and lead to nobody. If the stranger can't say they've seen his wife, the joker loser.
- Loser: Sal and Q
- Punishment: Sal and Q posed as hockey goalies for a New Jersey Devils pro hockey game. Unlike the other episodes, this punishment publicly stated that this was an Impractical Jokers episode and the two guys are being punished. Sal and Q had hockey uniforms and fell on the ice as goalies while former Devils players Colin White & Grant Marshall swung slap shot pucks at them. Sal and Q got their revenge in the British Invasion episode, where Joe and Murr were a target practice, for a professional football team (also known as soccer in America).
- This episode marks the first Sal and Q double punishment. The second one takes place in Lords of the Ring.