This article is about the episode. For the song, see Butterfly Crime Scene (Song).

Butterfly Crime Scene is the second episode of Season One of Impractical Jokers and the second episode overall. It originally aired on December 15, 2011 and had a total of 1.33 million U.S. viewers.


The group is challenged to apply the most lotion to beach-goers, survey amusement park guests at Six Flags Great Adventure, grab as many groceries from other customers at a grocery store as they can, and pay the least at a frozen yogurt shop.


Oceans of Lotion

Goal: Use as much sunscreen lotion possible on a person. Whoever uses up the least lotion loses.
Loser: Sal

Shopping Cart Lift

Goal: Take as many items as possible from a shopping cart (or the entire cart).
Loser: Sal

Survey Says

Goal: Say whatever is on the survey at Six Flags. Questions have little or nothing to do with the amusement park.
Loser: Murr

Weigh Too Much

Goal: Pay as little as possible for froyo
Loser: Joe, who was technically disqualified because he was sent out of the store.


Loser: Sal
Punishment: At a Lakewood BlueClaws baseball game, the other Jokers make up a song for him to sing on the spot. The name was provided for him, Butterfly Crime Scene.